Cap Table Decoded

ComparisonEquity Fundamentals

RSUs vs. Stock Options: What Each Is Worth to You

One is a share delivered to you. The other is the right to buy one. That difference decides what you pay, when you owe tax and what you keep if you leave.

Last reviewed

The short answer

  • A restricted stock unit (RSU) is a promise to give you a share once it vests. You pay nothing for it, and it is taxed as wages when the share is delivered.
  • A stock option is the right to buy a share later at a fixed strike price. It is worth only the gap between the share's value and that price, and you have to pay the strike, and often tax, to turn it into stock.
  • Options give more upside per dollar of grant value and can be bought early and cheaply at a young company. RSUs keep some value even when the share price falls, and need no cash from you. Which is better depends on the company's stage and how far its value can still rise.

RSUs and stock options side by side

How the two instruments differ, term by term
RSUsStock options
What you getA promise of one share per unit, delivered when it vestsThe right to buy one share per option at a fixed strike price
What you payNothingThe strike price for every option you exercise
What it's worthThe full value of the shareOnly the share's value above the strike price (the spread)
If the share price fallsWorth less, but still worth something while the share isWorthless to exercise once the share is below the strike (underwater)
When you're taxedWhen the shares are delivered, as ordinary wage incomeNSOs: at exercise, on the spread, as ordinary income. ISOs: no regular tax at exercise, but the spread can trigger AMT
Can you buy early with an 83(b) election?NoYes, if the plan allows early exercise
When you leaveUnvested units are forfeited; vested shares are yours (private-company RSUs may wait for a liquidity event)Unvested options are forfeited; vested options must be exercised within the post-termination window or they expire
Where you usually see themPublic companies and late-stage private companiesSeed to growth-stage startups

How RSUs work

An RSU grant is a number of units that turn into shares on a vesting schedule, most often over four years. Until a unit vests you own nothing: no vote, no dividends, nothing to sell. When it vests and the company delivers the share (called settlement), the full market value of that share counts as wage income on your W-2.

Because that income arrives as stock rather than cash, the company usually covers the tax by withholding some of the shares or selling some for you (sell-to-cover). The flat 22% federal rate the IRS allows for supplemental wages up to $1 million a year is often lower than what higher earners actually owe, so many people with large RSU grants owe more at tax time. Your state may tax it too. What you pay later, when you sell, is capital gains tax on any rise above the value at delivery.

At a public company the shares can be sold the day they arrive, outside trading blackout windows. That is the main reason an RSU offer from a public company is close to cash, and why comparing one to startup options takes a different kind of math.

Double-trigger RSUs at private companies

A private company can't simply deliver taxable shares every quarter: you would owe wage tax on stock you have no way to sell. So most private-company RSUs are double-trigger. They settle only when two conditions are both met:

  1. the time-based condition: your normal vesting schedule, and
  2. the liquidity condition: usually an IPO or an acquisition of the company.

Until the second trigger, nothing is taxed, and nothing can be sold either, except through a tender offer if the company runs one. When it happens, every unit that has met its time condition settles at once, and the whole value lands as income in that year. Plans usually set an expiration date on the liquidity condition, after which unsettled units lapse. Ask for that date, and ask whether units you have already time-vested stay yours if you leave before a liquidity event. Both are set by the plan, not by law, and they differ from company to company.

Don't confuse double-trigger RSUs with double-trigger acceleration, which is about vesting faster if you are let go after an acquisition. The cliff and vesting guide covers that.

How stock options work

An option grant fixes a strike price on the day it is granted, set at the fair market value of the common stock from the company's latest 409A valuation. As your options vest you can exercise them: pay the strike price and receive the shares. Your gain is the spread between what a share is worth and what you paid for it.

Startup options come in two tax types. With non-qualified options (NSOs), the spread at exercise is ordinary income, taxed like salary. With incentive stock options (ISOs), there is no regular income tax at exercise, and a sale that meets the holding periods is taxed entirely as long-term capital gains, but the spread counts toward the alternative minimum tax. The ISOs vs. NSOs guide walks through both.

Options also offer something RSUs can't: at an early company you may be allowed to exercise before you vest and file an 83(b) election within 30 days. When the strike equals the current value there is little or no spread to tax, and your holding period starts early. How that works, and the risk of paying for shares that may end up worthless, is in Early Exercise and Section 83(b) Elections.

What each is worth: a worked example

Because an RSU is worth the whole share and an option only the spread, a company targeting the same grant value hands out far fewer RSUs than options. The made-up grant below shows how differently the two pay out. The numbers are for illustration only, not a market rate for either instrument.

Illustrative only: 10,000 options with a $2.00 strike, or 2,500 RSUs, before tax
Share value at exit10,000 options at $2.002,500 RSUs
$1.50$0 (underwater)$3,750
$3.00$10,000 gain, after paying $20,000 to exercise$7,500
$10.00$80,000 gain, after paying $20,000 to exercise$25,000

The pattern holds for any numbers you put in. Options win by a growing margin the higher the share value climbs above the strike. RSUs win when the value stays flat or falls, and they never ask you to put cash in. To run this on your own offer, start from the strike price and share counts in your grant, then weigh the outcomes the way Calculating Expected Value of Options describes.

What happens when you leave

With either instrument, anything unvested on your last day is gone. The difference is in what you've already vested.

  • Vested options have to be exercised, and paid for, within the post-termination exercise window, commonly 90 days, or they expire. ISOs not exercised within three months of leaving lose their ISO tax treatment even if the company extends the window. See Post-Termination Exercise Windows.
  • Vested RSUs at a public company are shares you already own. You keep them and owe nothing more to hold them.
  • Time-vested, double-trigger RSUs at a private company depend on the plan. Many let you keep them until the liquidity event or the expiration date, whichever comes first. Read the plan before you resign.

That is why RSUs can be the easier grant to walk away from: there is no exercise bill due within weeks of your last day.

Which is better at your company's stage

Companies mostly decide this for you, and the choice says something about where they think they are.

  • Seed to Series B: options are the norm. The 409A value of common stock is low, so strikes are cheap, early exercise is affordable, and the room for the share price to grow is the whole point of the grant.
  • Late-stage private: as the 409A value rises, options get expensive to exercise and their remaining upside shrinks, so many companies move new hires to double-trigger RSUs. You give up some upside in exchange for not paying to exercise and not facing an exercise deadline when you leave. Liquidity still waits on an IPO, an acquisition or a tender offer, as the AI lab comparison shows.
  • Public: RSUs are standard. They behave like a cash bonus paid in stock that moves with the share price.

If you're choosing between offers, don't compare the number of units or options. Compare what each grant pays across a few realistic exit values, after strike costs and tax, and how long until you can sell. Decoding the Startup Offer Letter lists the documents that hold those terms.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • For RSUs: are they single- or double-trigger? What counts as a liquidity event, and when do unsettled units expire?
  • For RSUs: if I leave before a liquidity event, do I keep the units I have time-vested?
  • For RSUs: how will tax be withheld at settlement, by withholding shares, sell-to-cover or cash?
  • For options: are they ISOs or NSOs, what is the strike price, and what was the date of the 409A valuation behind it?
  • For options: can I exercise early, and how long is the post-termination exercise window?
  • For both: how many fully diluted shares are outstanding, so I can turn my grant into a percentage? See What Fully Diluted Shares Outstanding Means.

Frequently asked questions

Are RSUs better than stock options?

Neither is better everywhere. RSUs are worth more when the share price stays flat or falls, and they never cost you cash to receive. Options are worth more when the share price rises well above the strike price, which is why early-stage startups grant them.

Do you pay to get RSUs?

No. RSUs cost nothing to receive. You owe income tax on their value when the shares are delivered, and companies usually withhold or sell some of the shares to cover it.

Can you file an 83(b) election on RSUs?

No. An 83(b) election applies to property you receive that is still subject to vesting, such as early-exercised option shares or restricted stock. RSUs are only a promise of future shares, so there is nothing to make the election on.

What is a double-trigger RSU?

An RSU that settles only after two conditions are met: your normal time-based vesting and a liquidity event such as an IPO or acquisition. Private companies use them so employees aren't taxed on shares they can't sell.

Why do startups give options instead of RSUs?

Early on, the 409A value of common stock is low, so options are cheap to exercise and carry a lot of upside. RSUs at a private company also need a liquidity event before they can pay out without leaving employees a tax bill. Many companies switch to RSUs as their valuation rises.

Go deeper