Cap Table Decoded
Cap Table DecodedDecoding the Startup Offer Letter Before You Sign

Decoding the Startup Offer Letter Before You Sign

Know what equity details the offer letter doesn't tell you about your actual stake.

· 8 min read

A startup offer letter gives an engineer enough information to sign, but often not enough to judge the deal. Decoding it means separating cash you can count on from equity whose value depends on missing terms. The real offer is the salary and share count with ownership, exercise costs, dilution, and departure terms made clear.

Why the offer letter is designed to be just enough to sign

“50,000 options” sounds substantial until you ask how many shares the company has in total. Without that denominator, the count serves as an anchor. A letter can name the role, salary, grant, and vesting schedule while leaving the economics unresolved. Legal sufficiency and enough information to make a decision are different things.

That gap is built into what the document covers. The fully diluted percentage, strike price context, dilution path, refresh policy, and exercise window may be absent or buried elsewhere. None is a decorative detail. Together, they determine what the grant costs, how much ownership it represents, and whether you can keep it when you leave.

How base salary reads differently at each funding stage

Base salary is the easiest number to read because it is actual pay. But funding stage changes what that number means within the package. At seed, the cash-and-equity trade-off reflects a different stage of the company than it does at Series A. Looking at base alone leaves out the funding stage and treats different bets as though they were the same.

Founding engineer salaries typically run below market, and that shortfall is a real cost. An engineer who gives up meaningful base over four years is effectively investing that amount in the company at its current valuation. The sacrifice belongs in the evaluation at its full size just as surely as the salary does, however enthusiastically the offer describes the equity.

The practical approach is to treat base as the floor you can live on. Then evaluate the rest of the package as the bet. This makes the cash you forgo visible before a large option count distracts from it.

What the equity clause actually says and what it leaves out

The standard equity clause usually gives you the number of options, the option type, the vesting schedule, and the cliff. Those terms explain what is being granted and when you earn it. They do not, by themselves, explain its value. For that, you need the fully diluted ownership percentage, current 409A strike price, last preferred stock valuation, dilution outlook, refresh policy, and exercise window.

The option type affects the tax due on exercise. ISOs can give employees favorable tax treatment. NSOs are taxed as ordinary income on the spread at exercise. The letter should identify which type you are receiving, and you should ask for any missing clarification because that distinction provides essential context alongside tax advice.

The standard four-year vest with a one-year cliff means 25% vests at the twelve-month mark, followed by monthly vesting over the remaining thirty-six months. The schedule protects both sides and is what you should expect to see. The percentage tells you your stake in the company, while the share count tells you only how many units make up that stake.

How to read the equity percentage against your hire number and the company's stage

Once the percentage is clear, the next question is whether it fits the job and the point at which you are joining. A founding engineer grant needs founding engineer context. It cannot serve as a universal benchmark for a later hire or a different funding stage. What the percentage means depends on hire number, seniority, and stage.

Pave’s founding engineer data gives a useful calibration for a senior founding engineer in US Tier 1. The median is 0.33%, the 75th percentile is 0.62%, and the 90th percentile is 1.24%. These figures describe a distribution. They help show which offers need to be explained, without setting what every candidate should get.

The limits of the comparison matter as much as the figures. This benchmark does not establish a separate range for every early hire or for a senior engineer at Series A. Where the role or stage differs, the comparison becomes less direct. The company should be able to explain the grant in the context of when you are joining and the responsibility you are taking on.

Why the 409A strike price is not optional context

Options give you the right to buy shares, so vesting does not remove the bill for owning them. For a grant of 50,000 options, you must pay the strike price for each option to exercise the whole grant, plus any exercise-related taxes. Without the strike price, you cannot calculate that cost.

The 409A valuation establishes the fair market value of common stock used to set the strike. Under IRC §409A, options must be granted at or above that value on the grant date. Options granted below fair market value are treated as deferred compensation, triggering a 20% penalty tax on the employee plus interest. A valuation problem at the company can therefore become a tax problem for you.

The 409A valuation is almost always below the price investors paid for preferred shares. Those are different share classes, so the preferred price provides context rather than an interchangeable value for your common shares. Ask when the last 409A was completed and whether a new round has closed since then. A stale or unsupported valuation is not optional background to the deal.

What the 90-day exercise window clause costs you when you leave

Leaving can turn vested equity into a five- or six-figure cash decision with 90 days to act. You must pay the strike price for the shares you want to own. For NSOs, ordinary income taxes on the spread between the strike and current fair market value add to the upfront cost. If the window closes before you exercise, the vested options expire worthless.

That is what the standard 90-day post-termination exercise window means in practice. Years of vesting do not protect options from expiry after departure. The relevant wording may be “post-termination exercise period” or “post-separation exercise window” in the offer or equity plan. It needs as close a look as the grant size because it sets whether you can afford to keep the grant.

Some startups offer five- to ten-year post-termination exercise windows, and an extension can be negotiated. If the documents default to 90 days, ask whether the company will extend the window contractually before signing. Exercising before vesting with an 83(b) election can lower the tax owed on ISOs over time, but that needs its own legal and tax review.

How dilution will reduce your ownership between now and exit

Even a grant you can afford to exercise will not necessarily retain its starting ownership percentage. In future funding rounds, the company issues new shares, which leave existing holders with less of the total. Your share count can stay the same while your percentage falls. A founding engineer grant at seed may therefore represent materially less ownership by a meaningful exit.

That reduction is not automatically a loss of value. A smaller percentage of a more valuable company can be worth more. The problem comes when growth does not compensate for dilution, as can happen in a flat or down round. The offer’s starting percentage is a snapshot of your stake at the offer date.

Ask how many authorized shares exist, what the current fully diluted count is, and whether the company plans a raise in the next twelve months. A planned raise needs to be part of how you work out your percentage before you sign. Liquidation preferences also affect proceeds because investors often have priority over common stockholders at exit. A 1x non-participating liquidation preference is standard, but anything more aggressive needs a closer look. Your paper ownership value is not necessarily what you would receive.

Refresh grants and acceleration clauses — the terms that determine long-term value

Dilution is not the only reason the initial grant cannot describe the whole relationship. Refresh grants continue equity compensation after the initial four-year vest. These additional option grants help retain employees who have fully vested, but the offer letter typically does not commit to them. Ask whether a refresh policy exists. Ask what triggers a new grant. Without a commitment, there is no new unvested equity holding a fully vested employee at the company.

Single-trigger acceleration speeds up vesting when an acquisition alone takes place. Double-trigger acceleration requires an acquisition plus a qualifying termination, which can be a layoff, role elimination, or constructive termination. Double-trigger protection is the more common and defensible negotiated ask because it addresses being acquired and then losing the job with unvested equity gone.

These are terms to negotiate before signing. Prioritize grant size and the stated ownership percentage first. Then push on acceleration, the vesting cliff, the contractual post-termination exercise window, early-exercise rights, and refresh policy.

The contingency clauses that can unwind the offer after you've accepted

Compensation terms are not the only conditions in the letter. Standard contingencies include a background check, proof through I-9 verification that you are eligible to work, and signing separate agreements. But those conditions still apply after you accept a conditional offer.

The proprietary information and inventions assignment agreement, often called PIIA or CIAA, binds you to terms on intellectual property. It is typically a separate document signed at the start, and the offer should reference it by name. Ask for it before you sign the offer. Otherwise, you are accepting a requirement without having read the agreement it points to.

At-will language is also standard in most US states and means either party can end the relationship at any time. That is relevant context for verbal promises about role stability or future equity. If there is a signing bonus, its clawback condition, typically twelve months, must be explicit in the offer. A verbal agreement is not an enforceable substitute for that written condition.

The specific questions to ask before signing — and what the answers tell you

Start with ownership by asking the company to confirm the fully diluted share count so you can calculate your percentage. If the company refuses to share it, the basic size of the deal stays hidden. Then ask when the last 409A was completed and whether a new round has closed since then. That answer shows whether you need to check the quoted strike more closely against current fair market value.

Next, ask what post-termination exercise period the equity plan gives you and whether you can negotiate it. The response shows whether the company has thought about employees’ ability to keep their equity after leaving. Ask whether a raise is planned in the next twelve months. Ask what the current authorized share count is. The answer puts the ownership figure in the context of changes after the offer date.

Finally, ask about the refresh policy after the initial four-year vest and acceleration on acquisition or qualifying termination. No refresh answer means there is no clear policy to count on, while missing acceleration is a negotiating point before signing. These questions do more than fill gaps in a document. How a company responds to informed questions is itself a signal about the engineering organization you are joining.

Filed underOffer Valuation

More in Offer Valuation